Pro Bowl and All-Pro Calls
Scored under the published methodology, which sets out what counts as right, what a naive guess would have said, and why an earlier call is worth more than a late one.
- Takes logged
- 265
- Graded
- 65
- Average accuracy
- 0.0
- Pundits
- 69
25% settled
out of 100
have made one
How these calls land
Takes in each band
Settled or waiting
65 / 265
graded
200 still pending
By season
- 20230 of 5 graded
- 20242 of 2 graded
- 202563 of 89 graded
- 20260 of 169 graded
Who is good at pro bowl and all-pro calls
- JP Acosta0 accuracy · 22 graded-72.7
- Brandon Carney0 accuracy · 1 graded-100.0
- Peter Bukowski0 accuracy · 1 graded-100.0
- Pat Gustavson0 accuracy · 1 graded-100.0
- Danny Parkins0 accuracy · 1 graded-100.0
- Rhett Lewis0 accuracy · 1 graded-100.0
- Jeff "Coach Jags" Jagodzinski0 accuracy · 1 graded-100.0
- Rich Eisen0 accuracy · 2 graded-150.0
- Richard Sherman0 accuracy · 1 graded-161.0
- Shannon Sharpe0 accuracy · 1 graded-167.0
- Colin Cowherd0 accuracy · 2 graded-178.0
- Gregg Rosenthal0 accuracy · 2 graded-200.0
- Greg Cosell0 accuracy · 1 graded-200.0
- Nick Shook0 accuracy · 1 graded-200.0
- Daniel Jeremiah0 accuracy · 1 graded-200.0
- Jason Cabinda0 accuracy · 1 graded-200.0
- Nate Tice0 accuracy · 1 graded-200.0
- John Middlekauff0 accuracy · 1 graded-200.0
provisionalRatings this early are samples, not reputations — the methodology sets out how many articles it takes before we call one settled.
By publisher
- Pushing the Pile (podcast)0.0 · 44 graded
- Bran Coverage with BenchwarmerBran (podcast)0.0 · 2 graded
- Locked On Packers (podcast)0.0 · 2 graded
- First Things First (podcast)0.0 · 1 graded
- The Rich Eisen Show (podcast)0.0 · 2 graded
- Nightcap (podcast)0.0 · 1 graded
- Move the Sticks (podcast)0.0 · 4 graded
- The Herd with Colin Cowherd (podcast)0.0 · 4 graded
- Around the NFL (podcast)0.0 · 3 graded
- The 33rd Team0.0 · 1 graded
- The Colin Cowherd Podcast (podcast)0.0 · 1 graded
Every pro bowl and all-pro calls take
176–200 of 265
- Miss · 0Pushing the PilePro Bowl and All-Pro Calls2025 season
Jaxon Smith-Njigba to make First-Team All-Pro
We have JSN and Puka Nakula. I think those two, you don't even need to debate it.
a naive guess scored 100-100 skillsaid Jan 8, 2026 Leonard Williams to make First-Team All-Pro
My second first team all pro defensive tackle is Leonard Williams
- Miss · 0Pushing the PilePro Bowl and All-Pro Calls2025 season
Drake Maye to make First-Team All-Pro
Alright. Let's start at QB, which has been very hotly debated, but we both agree here. Going with Drake May.
Drake MayeNew England Patriots
a naive guess scored 100-100 skillsaid Jan 8, 2026 Jeffery Simmons to make First-Team All-Pro
The obvious one is Jeffrey Simmons for the Tennessee titans.
Devon Witherspoon to make First-Team All-Pro
And then my third corner, which is be sort of like a nickel, I have Deborah Witherspoon.
- Miss · 0Pushing the PilePro Bowl and All-Pro Calls2025 season
Puka Nacua to make First-Team All-Pro
We have JSN and Puka Nakula. I think those two, you don't even need to debate it.
a naive guess scored 100-100 skillsaid Jan 8, 2026 Pat Surtain II to make First-Team All-Pro
I went with Pat Sertain a second for my second, corner
- Miss · 0Pushing the PilePro Bowl and All-Pro Calls2025 season
Quinn Meinerz to make First-Team All-Pro
I have Quentin Nelson, Quinn Miners. You have Joe Tooney and Quinn Miners.
a naive guess scored 0+0 skillsaid Jan 8, 2026 Jack Campbell to make First-Team All-Pro
So linebacker, the one guy we agree on is Jack Campbell from Detroit Lions.
Trey McBride to make First-Team All-Pro
who are you going to who else are you going to give it to?... Trey McBride has been incredible
Puka Nacua to make First-Team All-Pro
We have JSN and Puka Nakula. I think those two, you don't even need to debate it.
Penei Sewell to make First-Team All-Pro
All pro OTs, we actually agree here. Again, Garrett Bowles, Pena Sewell.
- Miss · 0Pushing the PilePro Bowl and All-Pro Calls2025 season
Quinyon Mitchell to make First-Team All-Pro
And my other one, though, I didn't go certain. He would be second team all pro. I went Quinnyan Mitchell.
Quinyon MitchellPhiladelphia Eagles
a naive guess scored 100-100 skillsaid Jan 8, 2026 - Miss · 0Pushing the PilePro Bowl and All-Pro Calls2025 season
Ja'Marr Chase to make First-Team All-Pro
So third one we differ on. I have Ja'Marr Chase.
a naive guess scored 0+0 skillsaid Jan 8, 2026 Myles Garrett to make First-Team All-Pro
So all pro edge, obviously, Miles Garrett.
Aaron Brewer to make First-Team All-Pro
Aaron Brewer. Dolphin center. For my money, Aaron Brewer is the protector of the year.
Joe Thuney to make First-Team All-Pro
Yeah. What would Tooney instead of Quentin Nelson?... I think he gets to nod over Nelson for me.
Garett Bolles to make First-Team All-Pro
Yeah. I mean, at left tackle, it's been it was really tight this year between Garrett Bowles, Tristan Wirth... I'm glad that he's getting the recognition that he deserves
Quinn Meinerz to make First-Team All-Pro
You have Joe Tooney and Quinn Miners.
Derek Stingley Jr. to make First-Team All-Pro
So unanimously, we chose Derek Stingley junior.
Devin Lloyd to make First-Team All-Pro
My other all pro linebacker, I'm gonna be a homer. Don't care. It's Devin Lloyd.
Talanoa Hufanga to make First-Team All-Pro
I went with Tylenol Hufanga as my second all pro safety.
- Miss · 0Pushing the PilePro Bowl and All-Pro Calls2025 season
Bijan Robinson to make First-Team All-Pro
Let's get your running back where we both agree again. Not really debate here. It's Bijan Robinson.
a naive guess scored 100-100 skillsaid Jan 8, 2026 - Miss · 0Pushing the PilePro Bowl and All-Pro Calls2025 season
Jeffery Simmons to make First-Team All-Pro
Let's get to DT where similar situation. We have one that's obvious... The obvious one is Jeffrey Simmons for the Tennessee titans.
Jeffery SimmonsTennessee Titans
a naive guess scored 100-100 skillsaid Jan 8, 2026 - Miss · 0Pushing the PilePro Bowl and All-Pro Calls2025 season
Micah Parsons to make First-Team All-Pro
call me a homework if you want, but I want Micah Parsons. I I just think on a play for play basis, Micah Parsons was second most impactful guy.
Micah ParsonsGreen Bay Packers
a naive guess scored 100-100 skillsaid Jan 8, 2026
By sport
NFL — pro bowl and all-pro calls (65 graded)
The NFL is the only sport we cover today. This page exists so that adding a second one does not mean rewriting every link.