54 checkable claims from 35 pundits. These are other people’s predictions about what he will do — we grade the prediction, never the player.
Measurables
40-yard dash
4.68 s
Vertical
35½″
Broad jump
10′3″
Height
6′6″
Weight
236 lb
3-cone
7.06 s
20-yard shuttle
4.46 s
2020 NFL Scouting Combine. Drills not listed were not performed. Combine results via Pro-Football-Reference.com.
Who’s high on him, who’s low
Each pundit’s standing lean on Justin Herbert, measured against every other pundit who made a comparable call — same kind of claim, same season. +100 would mean the most bullish voice in every room; −100 the most bearish. At least two articles per pundit before a lean is shown, and the accuracy is how that pundit’s settled calls about him have graded out. A lean is a fact about the pundit, never a judgment of the player.
Highest on him
Bleacher Report+96
more bullish than 98% of the room, across 2 articles · 0.0 accuracy on him (1 settled)
more bearish than 82% of the room, across 2 articles · 56.9 accuracy on him (1 settled)
· for 2026
Justin Herbert to stay putChris Roling · for 2026 · said Oct 29, 2026
Justin Herbert to stay putJohn Middlekauff · for 2026 · said Oct 23, 2026
Justin Herbert to stay putJordan Dajani · for 2026 · said Oct 21, 2026
Justin Herbert to finish top 10 at his position, by an unstated measureChris Roling · for 2026 · said Oct 15, 2026
Justin Herbert to stay putChris Roling · for 2026 · said Oct 15, 2026
Justin Herbert to stay putBryan DeArdo · for 2026 · said Oct 13, 2026
Justin Herbert to move — “might just cost them Herbert, who appears to be in a funk only a change of scenery will solve”Chris Roling · for 2026 · said Oct 13, 2026
Justin Herbert to be 1st on the depth chartThomas Martinez · for 2026 · said Oct 11, 2026
Justin Herbert to be 1st on the depth chartThomas Martinez · for 2026 · said Oct 4, 2026
Justin Herbert to move — “could be traded if the season keeps collapsing, with a no-trade clause letting him hand-pick a destination”Tyler Sullivan · for 2026 · said Sep 28, 2026
Justin Herbert to stay putRalph Vacchiano · for 2026 · said Sep 28, 2026
Justin Herbert to be 1st on the depth chartThomas Martinez · for 2026 · said Sep 27, 2026
Justin Herbert to stay putRich Eisen · for 2026 · said Sep 21, 2026
Justin Herbert to be 1st on the depth chartThomas Martinez · for 2026 · said Sep 20, 2026
Justin Herbert to win MVPDanny Parkins · for 2026 · said Sep 11, 2026
Justin Herbert to finish top 1 at his position, by fantasy pointsFantasyPros · for 2026 · said Sep 9, 2026
Justin Herbert to finish top 5 at his position, by fantasy pointsWolf Trelles-Heard · for 2026 · said Sep 6, 2026
Justin Herbert to win MVP finalistChris Broussard · for 2026 · said Sep 2, 2026
Justin Herbert to win MVPVeejay Huskey · for 2026 · said Aug 30, 2026
Justin Herbert to outplay his draft cost (an ADP of QB9 and is going in the back half of the seventh round)Pat Fitzmaurice · for 2026 · said Aug 30, 2026
Justin Herbert to win MVPAlbert Breer · for 2026 · said Aug 28, 2026
Justin Herbert to win MVPDamon Bruce · for 2026 · said Aug 28, 2026
Justin Herbert to outplay his draft cost (9.01, QB14 ESPN ADP)Nic Bodiford · for 2026 · said Aug 27, 2026
Justin Herbert to outplay his draft cost (Round 7 or 8)Andrew Erickson · for 2026 · said Aug 22, 2026
Justin Herbert to outplay his draft cost (an ADP of QB9 and is going in the back half of the seventh round)Pat Fitzmaurice · for 2026 · said Aug 22, 2026
Justin Herbert to finish top 5 at his position, by fantasy pointsEvan Tarracciano · for 2026 · said Aug 19, 2026
Justin Herbert to finish top 13 at his position, by fantasy pointsFantasyPros · for 2026 · said Aug 19, 2026
Justin Herbert to fall short of his draft cost (QB8)FantasyPros · for 2026 · said Aug 19, 2026
Justin Herbert to finish top 1 at his position, by fantasy pointsNic Bodiford · for 2026 · said Aug 13, 2026
Justin Herbert to outplay his draft cost (the middle rounds)Pat Fitzmaurice · for 2026 · said Aug 11, 2026
Justin Herbert to outplay his draft cost (Round 7 or 8)Andrew Erickson · for 2026 · said Aug 8, 2026
Justin Herbert to finish top 10 at his position, by passing yardsDan Dwade · for 2026 · said Aug 7, 2026