Punditry Check ·
Cardinals: The Room Keeps Picking Arizona to Win Games It Loses
Arizona's score-pick punditry has been nearly uniformly wrong this season, even as roster and mock-draft calls on the Cardinals hold up well.
Sports desk
NFL posts
Our NFL writing from the graded record: a Punditry Check on one club a day, a digest of every game the room called, and the Pundit of the Week.
Game digest · Week 5 ·
Buccaneers 24, Cowboys 16: One in Nineteen Called the Upset
Tampa Bay's road win over Dallas settled 27 graded calls. Nineteen pundits picked a side — 18 took the Cowboys. Here's who got it right, and who didn't.
Pundit of the Week · Sep 28–Oct 4 ·
Joe Marino Sweeps the Week on Linebacker Grades and a Bills Roster Call
Joe Marino takes both Pundit of the Week honors for 2026-W40, built on a near-perfect slate of graded linebacker grades and a Bills roster call.
Latest
Punditry Check ·
Commanders: Division and Playoff Calls Busted at Zero, Roster Projections Nearly Perfect
Washington Commanders punditry graded: preseason contender calls for 2025 cratered, while roster and mock-draft projections held up well.
Punditry Check ·
Titans: The Mocks Missed Carnell Tate, and the Week 1 Pick Missed Worse
Tennessee Titans punditry, graded: mock drafts whiffed on the real No. 4 pick, Week 1 backers got blown out, and the room already has Tennessee picking high again.
Punditry Check ·
Seahawks: The Room Got Burned on Washington, Then Got the Chargers Almost Perfectly Right
Seattle Seahawks punditry graded: a near-unanimous Week 3 miss against Washington, a near-perfect Week 4 bounce back, and who's earned trust on this club.
Game digests · Oct 2–Oct 6 · 16 posts
Week 4 game digests
- Falcons 45, Saints 24
- 49ers 24, Broncos 14
- Ravens 24, Titans 18
- Patriots 29, Bills 26
- Rams 24, Eagles 20
- Packers 17, Buccaneers 14
- Panthers 32, Lions 26
- Bears 23, Jets 12
- Cowboys 34, Texans 30
- Jaguars 22, Bengals 17
- Vikings 15, Dolphins 10
- Chiefs 30, Raiders 27
- Seahawks 30, Chargers 23
- Giants 36, Cardinals 24
- Colts 30, Commanders 13
- Browns 27, Steelers 24
Punditry Check ·
49ers: Playoff Calls Nail It, Division-Winner Calls Keep Missing
The 49ers are 3-0 and pundits are piling on again, but graded calls show their division-winner picks on San Francisco have been the room's weakest link.
Punditry Check ·
Steelers: Opinions Took Pittsburgh Over Cleveland, and Cleveland Won
Pittsburgh punditry graded: 13 of 17 voices picked the Steelers over the Browns and lost, roster-spot calls are strong, and win-loss picks are weak.
Punditry Check ·
Eagles: A Bears Blowout Burned Every Caller, Jeff Kerr's Record Still Holds
Philadelphia pundit calls, graded: a Monday-night wipeout against Chicago burned the field, roster-spot calls hold up, and win-total forecasts split widely.