110 checkable claims from 54 pundits. These are other people’s predictions about what he will do — we grade the prediction, never the player.
Median call across 3 pundits: 2,000 rushing yards
Measurables
40-yard dash
4.39 s
Vertical
36″
Broad jump
10′3″
Bench press
17 reps
Height
5′10″
Weight
226 lb
3-cone
7.01 s
20-yard shuttle
4.24 s
2020 NFL Scouting Combine. Drills not listed were not performed. Combine results via Pro-Football-Reference.com.
Page 1 of 3 — unsettled claims first, then the settled ones, newest first.
What pundits expect · 40 on this page
Not settled yet. These are graded once the season or event they describe has finished.
Jonathan Taylor to stay putCarter Bahns · for 2026 · said Nov 11, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to finish RB1 (1–12) at his position, by fantasy pointsAndrew Erickson · for 2026 · said Nov 11, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to stay putGarrett Podell · for 2026 · said Nov 11, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to stay putGarrett Podell · for 2026 · said Nov 10, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “won't be a Colt for long”Dan Gartland · for 2026 · said Nov 10, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to be 1st on the depth chartEvan Tarracciano · for 2026 · said Nov 10, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “the Colts will move RB Jonathan Taylor before the deadline”
FantasyPros · for 2026 · said Nov 10, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “trade appears likely”Michael David Smith · for 2026 · said Nov 9, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “will move RB Jonathan Taylor before the deadline”FantasyPros · for 2026 · said Nov 9, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “could be on the move”Carter Bahns · for 2026 · said Nov 9, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “the Colts will move him before the deadline”Pat Fitzmaurice · for 2026 · said Nov 9, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “could go from pipe dream to reality”Ryan Wilson · for 2026 · said Nov 9, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “gets dealt”Dan Beyer · for 2026 · said Nov 9, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “if the Colts get what they want, he's going to be moved”Adam Caplan · for 2026 · said Nov 9, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “traded to Minnesota”Zachary Pereles · for 2026 · said Nov 9, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to stay putJordan Dajani · for 2026 · said Nov 9, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “traded to the Vikings in a package deal before the deadline”Mike Florio · for 2026 · said Nov 7, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “most likely to be traded ahead of the November 10th deadline”Noah Compton · for 2026 · said Nov 7, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “might be his last game as a Colt in Lucas Oil Stadium”Jake Arthur · for 2026 · said Nov 7, 2026
“I do think that he plays and I do think the Colts run him out there. (Week 9, Cowboys at Colts)”Derek Brown · for 2026 · said Nov 7, 2026
“I think there's a chance the Colts either don't play him or barely play him... I would not be surprised if he were…”Pat Fitzmaurice · for 2026 · said Nov 7, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “gets traded”Ian Rapoport · for 2026 · said Nov 6, 2026
“So I expect him to go out and play this weekend.”Ian Rapoport · for 2026 · said Nov 6, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “trade for Jonathan Taylor”Matt Harmon · for 2026 · said Nov 5, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to be 1st on the depth chartChad Jensen · for 2026 · said Nov 5, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “will be here (stays unless they get a first-round pick)”Darius Butler · for 2026 · said Nov 4, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “will likely be dealt at the trade deadline”Frank Ammirante · for 2026 · said Nov 4, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “the Colts move on from him (traded)”Raymond Summerlin · for 2026 · said Nov 3, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “a deal will get done, and Taylor will be in a better situation shortly”Jim Moorman · for 2026 · said Nov 3, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “traded to the Bengals”Zach Pressnell · for 2026 · said Nov 3, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “traded by the Indianapolis Colts”Nathan Jahnke · for 2026 · said Nov 3, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “Seattle giving up a first or a second round pick and upgrading to Jonathan Taylor”Colin Cowherd · for 2026 · said Nov 3, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “seems he's gonna get traded”Dan Orlovsky · for 2026 · said Nov 2, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “a Jonathan Taylor trade feeling inevitable”Peter Miller · for 2026 · said Nov 2, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “could be next [to be traded]”Tyler Sullivan · for 2026 · said Nov 2, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “should be wearing a new uniform by this time next week”Evan Tarracciano · for 2026 · said Nov 2, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “gone this week (traded by the Colts)”Rich Eisen · for 2026 · said Nov 2, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to stay putChad Jensen · for 2026 · said Nov 2, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “gets traded, possibly to the Giants”Dan Graziano · for 2026 · said Nov 2, 2026
Jonathan Taylor to move — “gets traded for at least a second-round pick plus additional compensation”Jordan Schultz · for 2026 · said Nov 2, 2026